Indiana Jones vs. Fundamental Law of Conservation of Mechanical Energy

The Indiana Jones movie series is full of scenarios where characters use ropes, chains, and whips to swing from one place to another. From a physics perspective, this swinging motion is a perfect example of the law of conservation of mechanical energy. The law of conservation of mechanical energy states that the total potential and kinetic energy in a system will remain constant as long as the only forces that act on the system are conservative. This law can be written as follows:

KEi+PEi=KEf+PEf

Where the initial and final mechanical energy is measured at these points in the swing path:
Classic Rope Swing

When starting from rest in the initial position above, the only energy in the system is in the form of potential energy, since kinetic energy is associated with movement. At the bottom of the swing, there is solely kinetic energy in the system since the bottom of the swing path is considered at ground level. Therefore, the change in potential energy as it drops distance (h) is transferred into kinetic energy. The mechanical energy conservation can thus be written as:
PEi=KEi

  • Where PE is measured as mass(m) * acceleration on Earth due to gravity(g) * height (h) Or, (mgh), and the kinetic energy is ½ * m * velocity(v)^2, or (½ mv^2)

The mechanical energy conservation now takes the form of:


mgh=1/2mv^2

Now that there is a foundation to begin analyzing a conservation of mechanial energy scenario, let’s check out a scene from Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull. Here is the scene:
What is interesting about this scene is that the car is traveling at a pretty high speed, and the only way for Mutt Williams to gain this speed is if he started from a sufficient height. The height in this scene can be taken from the following moment:


It appears that Mutt only falls about two times his own height. The height of Mutt is 5’9”, which is about 1.75 meters. Using double his height for the potential energy, the total mechanical energy initially can be written as:

Mechanical Energy Initial = (72kg)*(9.8m/s^2)*(2)(1.75m) = 2470J
It appears that the car is moving at about 50mph, or 22m/s. Is the initial mechanical energy of the system enough to allow Mutt to travel that fast at the bottom of the vine swing?
In order to figure this out, we must rearrange the mechanical energy equation in order to solve for the speed of Mutt at the bottom if the swing.
mgh=1/2mv^2

gh=1/2v^2

(2gh)^½=v

(2*9.8m/s*2*1.75m)^½= 8.30m/s

This speed is about a third of the speed that is necessary for Mutt to actually catch up to the car. This proves that the movie disregarded the fundamental law of conservation of mechanical energy. Although disappointing, it is a crucial aspect of the movie series for Indiana Jones and other characters to perform impossible stunts for the sole purpose of entertainment.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Avengers: Infinity War Movie Analysis

Image
Avengers: Infinity War is another classic superhero movie that involves action scenes made more epic by violating the laws of physics. That being said, it took some time to find scenes that involved spotty physics. Here are a few that caught my eye.  Scene One - Cull Obsidian's Hammer Throw In the battle scene between Black Order and the Avengers in New York City, Cull Obsidian's hammer seems to be resistent to Newtons first law when it is in contact with a concrete wall, but abides by it when interacting with the ground. Newtons first law states that a body will remain at rest or move in a straight line at a constant speed unless acted upon by a net outside force.  1:38-1:42 Notice how the hammer travels straight through the building without slowing down whatsoever. Comparing this to newtons first law, it seems that the hammer is resistent to any outside forces. Now look at this scene where the hammer is slowed down dramatically by the ground. 1:55-
Read more

The Twin Paradox vs. Contact

Image
     The movie Contact makes an effort to display a realistic representation of the Twin Paradox, but the fundamental concept of time dilation was displayed incorrectly. The time dilation in the twin paradox is a result of the point of view of a stationary observer seeing a clock move slower as it moves with a constant velocity past them. This can be portrayed in the diagram below:      Keep in mind that light in a vacuum will always travel at the speed of light [c], which represents the second postulate of special relativity. The second section of the illustration above represents the actual motion of a photon in both a moving inertia frame and a stationary inertia frame. The third section of the illustration represents what a stationary observer would see as the clock moves by them at a constant velocity. Notice how the distance that the photon actually travels (2d) is shorter than the distance that the stationary observer sees. To the stationary observer, the photon travels a l
Read more

Interstellar's Display of a Wormhole and the Physics Behind It

Image
The movie Interstellar displayed many astrophysical phenomena of which had barely ever been displayed in major motion pictures before. In able to gain a good foundation for the physics behind wormholes, I read chapter 14 and 15 of the book The Science Behind Interstellar  by author Kip Thorne. The wormhole displayed in the move was what Thorne referred to as a "traversable wormhole". A traversable wormhole's properties that make it different than a normal one is that it contains exotic matter. A traversable wormhole can most likely only be created unnaturaly. This is because the only exotic mater that humans have ever encountered is when we created it in a labratory. Spacetime is converged when seen from outside of the wormhole, but diverged when seen from inside the wormhole. A simple mass will cause spacetime to be converged, such as the top of Figure 1, but the divergence of spacetime requires a negative mass, or negative energy, in accordance to Einstein's
Read more